Last Wednesday everyone went crazy when CERN scientists announced proof of the existence of the Higgs boson, which theoretically gives us mass and holds the Universe together. Now, other physicists say that CERN may have found an impostor and notthe popularly called God Particle.
After analyzing the data collected at CERN’s Large Hadron Collider, scientists Ian Low, Joseph Lykken and Gabe Shaughnessy at the Argonne National Laboratory in Illinois, claim that these observations may be explained by two other “impostor” particles, which may be masquerading as the fabled Higgs boson:
We show that current LHC data already strongly disfavor both the dilatonic and non-dilatonic singlet imposters. On the other hand, a generic Higgs doublet and a triplet imposter give equally good fits to the measured event rates of the newly observed scalar resonance
In their 20-page research paper—available through Cornell University’s Arxiv (PDF)—Low and his colleagues also add that, while the data may be explained by these two impostors, the “Standard Model Higgs boson gives a slightly better overall fit.”
If they are right, however, the 30-year $9-billion quest to find the holy grail of physics, may have not ended yet.
Indeed, this is nothing to be surprised about. When CERN scientists claimed that they were 99.9999 percent sure that the measurements are the result of the existence of the Higgs boson, they were cautious in their optimism, saying they needed to investigate more.
Joe Incandela, professor of physics at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and head of the LHC’s Compact Muon Solenoid experiment, didn’t want to point at the Higgs boson just yet:
The results are preliminary but the 5 sigma signal at around 125 GeV we’re seeing is dramatic. This is indeed a new particle. We know it must be a boson and it’s the heaviest boson ever found. The implications are very significant and it is precisely for this reason that we must be extremely diligent in all of our studies and cross-checks.
The reason for his controlled optimism is the elusive nature of this particles. Since we can only create them for a very limited time before they decay into other particles, it’s very difficult to trace their signature. It’s even more difficult when, looking at the the data so far collected by CERN, the signature can be attributed to other particles.
That’s why Low and his colleagues conclude that we need to wait and get more information, since the data at this stage cannot completely demonstrate the existence of the God particle or even these impostors.